Physical Restraint & Seclusion Injuries

Restraint and seclusion are meant to be rare, short and used only to stop immediate danger. When they are used for discipline, convenience or too long, or done the wrong way, people can be hurt or killed. Physical restraint and seclusion injury claims ask whether the hold was allowed at all, whether it was done safely and whether staff watched and responded. A restraint injury lawyer looks at the rules that applied in that setting and what the records and video show.

What counts as restraint and seclusion

Federal hospital rules define restraint as any manual method, physical or mechanical device or material that limits a person's ability to move their arms, legs, body or head, and also a drug used to manage behavior or restrict movement that is not standard treatment for the person's condition1. Seclusion is involuntary confinement alone in a room or area the person is physically prevented from leaving1.

• Physical or manual holds by staff
• Mechanical restraints such as straps or belts
• Chemical restraint: a drug used for control, not treatment
• Seclusion rooms and locked isolation

When the rules allow it

In hospitals that take Medicare and Medicaid, patients have a right to be free from restraint or seclusion used as coercion, discipline, convenience or retaliation1. Restraint or seclusion may be used only to ensure immediate physical safety, only when less restrictive steps have not worked, and must end at the earliest possible time1.

Key federal hospital requirements

Orders

From a physician or other licensed practitioner; never standing or as-needed orders1.

Time limits

For violent or self-destructive behavior, each order lasts up to 4 hours for adults, 2 hours for ages 9-17 and 1 hour for children under 91.

Face-to-face check

Within one hour of starting restraint or seclusion for violent or self-destructive behavior1.

Training

Staff must be trained before using restraint, including recognizing positional asphyxia and CPR1.

Death reporting

Deaths during or soon after restraint or seclusion must be reported to CMS1.

Psychiatric residential treatment facilities for people under 21 have their own federal rules, with similar limits, a one-hour face-to-face assessment and reporting of serious occurrences2. Schools, group homes and private programs are governed mostly by state law, which varies.

How restraint causes injury and death

Face-down holds are among the most dangerous. In a 2009 review of selected cases, GAO found that in each of four deaths it examined, the restraint restricted the flow of air to the lungs3. Other harms include:

• Asphyxia from weight on the back or chest
• Fractures, dislocations and head injuries
• Cardiac events during struggle
• Blood clots after long mechanical restraint
• Injuries from falls into or out of holds
• Lasting psychological harm, including trauma symptoms

Schools, hospitals and programs

Restraint and seclusion happen in many places, and the rules differ:

• Hospitals and psychiatric units: federal hospital rules plus state law1
• Youth psychiatric residential treatment facilities: federal PRTF rules plus state licensing2; see Residential Treatment Facility Abuse
• Public and private schools: GAO found no federal regulations on restraint in schools in 2009, and state laws varied widely3
• Group homes: state rules and the person's care plan; see Group Home & Behavioral Health Neglect
• Jails and police custody: civil rights rules; see Suicide in Custody or Institutional Care

Filing deadlines for a restraint and seclusion lawsuit

Deadlines depend on the state, the type of defendant and when the injury was discovered. Examples:

• Arizona: generally two years for personal injury and wrongful death4, and claims against a public entity or public employee must first be filed within 180 days5 Claims against licensed health care professionals also need a certification about expert testimony early in the case6.
• California: two years for injury or death caused by another's wrongful act or neglect7. Separate, shorter rules can apply to claims against health care providers and public agencies.
• New York: three years for most personal injury claims8; two years and six months for medical malpractice, measured from the act or the end of continuous treatment for the same condition9; and a notice of claim within 90 days for most claims against a public entity10.
• Texas: two years for personal injury and wrongful death11. Claims against health care providers follow their own statute with added requirements.
• Federal facilities, such as a VA hospital or a federal prison: a written claim must first go to the federal agency, generally within two years12, before any lawsuit13.

Rules for children, people who lacked capacity and wrongful death claims can differ. Ask a restraint injury attorney to check the deadlines for your state early, while records still exist.

Tell Us Your Story →

Records that help a review

Records worth gathering

Incident

• Restraint or seclusion orders and logs
• Incident reports
• Video footage

Medical

• Emergency and hospital records
• Photos of injuries
• Autopsy report, if a death occurred

School or program

• Behavior plans and IEPs
• Notices sent to parents
• Policies and training records

Ask about video quickly. Some systems record over footage within days or weeks.

What happens after you contact CBW Law

How a review works

1. Tell us what happened

   Tell us where it happened and what injury followed. You do not need records first.

2. We identify the rules that applied

   We match the setting to the federal and state rules that governed the hold.

3. We gather records

   With your permission, we request treatment, facility and billing records from the places involved.

4. We explain what we see

   We tell you what the records show, what questions remain and what options may be open, including deadlines.

Restraint is an emergency measure, not a way to manage a person.

Plain English

Medical, Health & Insurance

Terms you may see in restraint and seclusion records.

Restraint terms

Prone restraint

A hold with the person face down.

Mechanical restraint

A device, such as straps, used to limit movement.

Chemical restraint

A drug used to control behavior that is not standard treatment1.

Medical terms

Positional asphyxia

Breathing failure caused by body position or pressure; a required training topic under federal hospital rules1.

Face-to-face evaluation

An in-person check within one hour of starting restraint or seclusion1.

Questions

Restraint and seclusion lawsuit questions

Short answers to the questions people ask first.

What is a restraint and seclusion lawsuit?

A claim that restraint or seclusion was used when it should not have been, or done unsafely, and that someone was hurt.

Is restraint ever allowed?

Yes, in limited emergencies. A restraint injury lawyer looks at whether the rules for that setting were followed.

My child was restrained at school. Does that support a claim?

Possibly. School rules vary by state, and a restraint injury attorney can explain what applied.

Is sedation a restraint?

It can be, if a drug was used to control behavior rather than as standard treatment.

Can a family bring a claim after a death?

Yes. A wrongful death claim may be available under state law.

Do I need a police report?

No. It is not required to ask for a review.

How long do I have to file?

It depends on the state and whether a public school or hospital is involved. Some notice periods are short.

What does it cost to contact CBW Law?

Telling us your story costs nothing, and contacting us does not create an attorney-client relationship.

Tell Us Your Story

If you or someone you love was hurt by restraint or seclusion, a restraint injury attorney can review what happened.

Tell us what happened. CBW Law will review your information and explain what we see. Submitting information does not establish an attorney-client relationship or guarantee representation.

Tell Us Your Story →Call (800) 476-2416

This page is general information about restraint and seclusion claims. It is not legal or medical advice and does not create an attorney-client relationship. Rules depend on the setting and the state. An injury during restraint does not by itself establish liability, and no outcome can be promised.