Stone arches and columns in a dim church cloister, with soft daylight beyond.

News Personal Injury

Second Jury Verdict Against Oakland Diocese: What It Means for Survivors

An Alameda County jury awarded $14.3 million on Nov. 17, 2026, to a woman who was sexually abused as a child in the 1970s by former priest Stephen Kiesle. The verdict is against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland. It is the second eight-figure verdict against the diocese this year, and it comes while the diocese is still in Chapter 11 bankruptcy.

What the Jury Decided

The jury in Alameda County Superior Court awarded $14.3 million in damages, the San Francisco Chronicle reported. The case was brought under a California law that took effect in 2020 and reopened older child sexual abuse claims.

In a statement to EWTN News, the diocese said it acknowledges the verdict and “continues to work towards that goal in the bankruptcy process,” meaning fair compensation for survivors.

Here is what public reports and court records show so far:

  • The verdict is against the Roman Catholic Diocese of Oakland, the same organization that is in bankruptcy
  • The total award is $14.3 million
  • The survivor is a woman who was abused as a child in the 1970s
  • The reports we reviewed do not break the award into categories, do not mention punitive damages and do not say how the jury divided fault
  • We could not confirm the trial judge, the case number or whether a final judgment has been entered

Who Was Held Responsible

Kiesle was ordained in 1972. He was arrested in 1978 for molesting two boys at his parish and received probation. He was asked to leave the priesthood in 1981, and the Vatican approved his removal in 1987. He later worked as a youth minister in Pinole until 2002. In 2004 he pleaded no contest to abusing a young girl and was sentenced to six years in prison, the Chronicle reported.

In the first trial this year, KQED reported, the diocese did not dispute that the abuse happened or that it failed to properly supervise Kiesle.

California’s Proposition 51 makes each defendant pay only its own share of fault for non-economic damages, such as pain and suffering. In October 2026, a state Court of Appeal ruled that this rule applies to child sexual abuse claims revived by the newer law. The decision is unpublished. Public reports do not say how this jury split fault between the diocese and anyone else.

The First Verdict, in April

On April 22, 2026, another Alameda County jury awarded $16 million to a man who was abused by Kiesle as a 10-year-old altar boy in Union City. KQED reported the award included $12 million for past harm and $4 million for future harm.

Every case is different. These verdicts do not predict the outcome of any other survivor’s case.

Why the Bankruptcy Matters to Survivors

The Roman Catholic Bishop of Oakland, the diocese’s legal name, filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy on May 8, 2023. The case is In re The Roman Catholic Bishop of Oakland, No. 23-40523, in the U.S. Bankruptcy Court for the Northern District of California. The diocese itself is the debtor in that case.

  • On Oct. 2, 2026, Bankruptcy Judge William J. Lafferty III refused to confirm the diocese’s reorganization plan. He found the diocese had not proven survivors would do at least as well under the plan as in a liquidation
  • Abuse survivors voted 331 to 8 against the plan, according to the decision
  • The plan would have paid up to $172.3 million into a survivors’ trust and sent abuse claims to that trust through a channeling injunction. Because the plan was not confirmed, that injunction is not in effect
  • The bankruptcy court had earlier allowed some state-court abuse cases to go forward to trial
  • After the April verdict, KQED reported that the award could not be collected from the diocese directly because of the bankruptcy stay, but that insurance coverage is not subject to the stay
  • Insurance coverage disputes are being litigated separately, the bankruptcy decision says

When, how and how much survivors with verdicts will be paid is unsettled. It depends on what happens next in the bankruptcy court, including whether a new plan is proposed and how insurance disputes are resolved. We are not able to predict the result.

What Survivors Can Do Now

  • Claims against the diocese itself are being handled through the bankruptcy case, which has its own rules
  • Other people or groups may also be involved in a case, such as religious orders, schools or insurers
  • Keep any letters, notices or claim forms you have received about the bankruptcy
  • Write down names, places and dates you remember, even if they seem small
  • Time to bring a claim is limited, and the rules are complex. Do not assume it is too late to ask

Our clergy and church sexual abuse page explains how claims against churches and religious orders work. Our institutional abuse page covers what organizations owe the people in their care, and our sexual assault and abuse overview covers civil claims more broadly.

If you were abused by a priest, a church worker or anyone in a position of trust, in Oakland or anywhere else, you can talk it through with us. Tell us your story.

This article is general information about how these cases work. It is not legal advice, it does not create an attorney-client relationship, and no two claims are alike. If something here sounds like your situation, the useful next step is a conversation about the facts.

Sources and citations

Statutes, regulations, agency material and decisions referred to above.

  1. Jury awards $14.3 million to victim of East Bay priestSan Francisco ChronicleNov. 17 Alameda County verdict of $14.3 million; claim under the law that reopened old child sexual abuse claims; Kiesle’s history; diocese statement; 2023 bankruptcy.
  2. Jury orders Oakland Diocese to pay $14 million to victim of priest abuseEWTN NewsDiocese statement to EWTN News on Nov. 18 acknowledging the verdict and referring to the bankruptcy process.
  3. Jury Awards $16 Million to Man Abused by East Bay Priest as a ChildKQEDApril verdict of $16 million ($12 million past, $4 million future harm); diocese did not dispute the abuse or its failure to supervise; award not collectible directly during the bankruptcy stay; insurance not subject to the stay.
  4. Memorandum Decision on Confirmation, In re The Roman Catholic Bishop of Oakland, No. 23-40523 WJLU.S. Bankruptcy Court, N.D. California (via GovInfo)Confirmation of the Modified Fourth Amended Plan denied; abuse claimant vote of 8 accept and 331 reject; up to $172.3 million survivors’ trust; channeling injunction in the proposed plan; earlier relief from stay for state-court cases; pending insurance coverage litigation.
  5. Plaintiffs in JCCP 5108 v. Superior Court, No. B349706 (unpublished)California Court of Appeal, Second District, Division FiveRevived childhood sexual abuse claims are subject to Proposition 51; liability for non-economic damages is several, not joint. Opinion filed Oct. 5, 2026; modified Oct. 30, 2026.
  6. Federal judge rejects the Oakland Diocese’s bankruptcy planThe OaklandsideOct. 2 ruling; survivors’ committee unanimously opposed the plan; bishop’s response.

Vetted by

Stefan Rest, managing director of CBW Law

Stefan Rest

Managing Director, CBW Law

Stefan Rest has spent more than two decades advocating for consumers and helping people understand how the law may provide a path forward when they’ve been wronged. As Managing Director of CBW Law, he oversees client relations, the firm’s national law-firm network and new partnerships. He writes about developing litigation and consumer legal issues because the right information can help people recognize when their own story may matter.

Last reviewed:

Attorney advertising. The content of this website may be considered attorney advertising under the rules of certain jurisdictions. The information on this website is for general information purposes only and should not be taken as legal advice for any individual case or situation. Viewing this site does not create an attorney-client relationship. Prior results do not guarantee a similar outcome. Statutes, regulations and case law change, and the law differs from state to state.